Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

4E Black Humor

Funny Onion-styles news report over at pats_quinade, Fourth Edition D&D Kills 3, Wounds 1.

The wailing and gnashing of teeth is getting a little out of hand for a game no one but a few playtesters have seen yet.


Nov. 11th, 2007 04:15 pm (UTC)
"Here's what's coming" makes a big difference (and man, I'd be thrilled to run a WotC preview in KQ, though I know it's a pipe dream). It's good to have something tangible for the upcoming game, something to drool over.

There's none of that now, just posts and pixels. They're trying pretty hard, with the staff blogs, but they are redacted enough that some of it just doesn't work as marketing. The coyness about the "new secret race" is meant to be a tease, but it is so transparent that it's just irritating. I've seen a million PC races: why should I care about this one?

The answer "because it's from WotC" is no longer sufficient, because I've played great PC races from Malhavoc (Oh the giants! AND the Littorians!) and my own.

The other big difference is the playtests. For 3E, everyone was a playtester, including all of the people who became 3E's third-party champions. You don't see the difference because you're in the loop, but for the rest of the world, it's a little different this time. The external playtests started too late to affect the core rules deeply, and the number of playtesters strikes me as smaller. But then, last time I was a lot closer to the closed content world.

Maybe the Net and Open companies have spoiled me for choice since last time. I'm not sure.

I am still waiting for the "Welcome to 4th Edition" group hug. The longer I wait, the more I just say: "Eh, I'm enjoying 3E. Get back to me when you have something to share." I'm less patient than last time, because I've seen this circus before. I just want it to ship, so I can make a decision.

Edited at 2007-11-11 04:17 pm (UTC)

Latest Month

April 2016

Game Design


Powered by LiveJournal.com